You make the call.. TD?

[obiefan]

I contend that this was NOT a touchdown...

You make the call...


http://www.massillonproud.com/zpics/albums/uploads/obievision/05mentor/cam2/nontd/nonTD1.jpg
Cam2 still captures...

http://www.massillonproud.com/zpics/albums/uploads/obievision/05mentor/cam2/nontd/nonTD2.jpg
Cam1 different angle

[npaflas]

Iguess we got rip off and should have won the game. GOtigers beat iggy

[mike_da_man13]

tough call

[obiefan]

We got ripped, but it still wouldn't have mattered... They scored another time after that to make it 19.. If the ref had made the call correctly, the score would have only been 12-7

[TigerDL71]

if you had one right down the goal line that would be perfect to truly tell or not

[tiger4life]

Is this a Mentor touchdown? This doesn't look like the touchdown in question at the half to me. It was on the far side of the endzone and that one was a touchdown for Massillon. Even Jeeter (sp) agrees.

[tiger4life]

My question on the last pic would would be where did the knees go down. After looking at this in photoshop and measureing the shadows I have to say it is not a touchdown. Scassa is filling the space necessary to allow the touchdown. The only way it could have been is the surge just before scassa puts his shoulder into him. I think you are right Jimbo.

[obiefan]

This was in the 3rd qtr. It was the Mentor go ahead score that made it 12-7 in Mentor's favor.

[longtimefirsttime]

Obiefan-Nice pics, but I can't tell.

[DAWGH8R]

Inconclusive !!!

[austinsm11]

Too hard to tell from the angle. I would say that he was in, but it is hard to tell where is knees are and hard to tell from the angle.